Closing, Remodeling and Merging, Oh My!
Friday, October 31st, 2008Recently, the Smyth County School Board met to discuss the state of several schools throughout the county. Most of the discussion revolved around the state of Marion Intermediate and Marion Primary Schools, and the future of Chilhowie High, Northwood High, and Sugar Grove Combined School.
While replacing Marion Intermediate and renovating Marion Primary were inevitable and welcomed topics of conversation, the focus of the meeting seemed to switch to the fate of three schools in the county.
The school board is currently considering closing Sugar Grove Combine School, a K-8 school with miniscule enrollment, found in the community of Sugar Grove on the Smyth-Grayson County line. Most notably, the school board discussed the consolidation of two county high schools, Chilhowie High and Northwood High School.
The options discussed at the meeting spoke of either bussing the Chilhowie students the additional ten miles on VA-107 to the current Northwood High School, or building a new school in between the two towns in an area called Midway.
Although the school board is quoted as saying, “Building, merging, consolidating…the student is the most important thing. It’s not what we want. It’s what’s best for them,” I don’t believe that they are taking the students’ concerns into consideration. Being a graduate of Chilhowie High School, I am admittedly biased, and I realize that enrollment and facility issues are often the deciding factor for closing or consolidating a school; however, I believe that the school board needs to consider the academic well-being of the students at Chilhowie High.
There was talk of consolidating when I was in high school, and I remember how scary of a thought that was. It wasn’t because of politics or petty rivalries, but because of the quality of education I received at Chilhowie High School. The smaller school allowed for closer communities within the school and better relationships between students, faculty, and staff.
Chilhowie and Northwood alike have always had reputations of academic excellence for their own reasons, and I believe that these schools should be allowed to exist separately and continue the success they have enjoyed throughout the years. I think that disrupting the legacy of Chilhowie High School and Northwood High School alike and trying to “mesh” them with that of another school could be a possible travesty for Smyth County School Systems.
I realize that a single, cohesive, consolidated school is years in the making, but I remind the school board that the main things—possibly the only things keeping these two communities alive—are the high schools. With very little economic development or growth in either town, it is imperative that the schools remain in their respective communities. Perhaps the school board needs to think twice before taking away that sense of pride and community involvement.
– Shai Cullop
http://www.swvatoday.com/comments/consolidation_closings_and_renovations_discussed/news/3790/